‘Detour
to Canada’, a debut work of Canada-based Keralite, Sunil Nair has a
simple storyline. An Indian student Vinu who has no focus in life
dreams of going to the United States of America. But future has
something else in store for him. He reaches Canada and he aspires to
go to the US from there. During his stay in Canada, his life and
perception changes. The elements that bring the change forms the crux
of the story. The book is too simple that the question, ‘does the
reader need such a simple tale at a time when technology rules the
roost’, pops up. It should have been told more than 20 years ago.
Even
the fact that this is the author’s debut book could not salvage him
from some of the grave mistakes he had committed here. Firstly, home
work, a prerequisite for any kind of endeavour is absent. Sadly, it
is too conspicuous that it can halt a reader from moving ahead with
the story.
There
are many such instances in the book that can prove it beyond doubt.
When Ramdas’s (Vinu’s father) cousin Raj calls from the USA, the
former inquires about the hurricane ‘Sandy’ that has hit America.
Ramdas who is unaware of the incident, would have known it from his
son who constantly googles about that country. To Ramdas’s query,
Raj expresses surprise and replies as follows - ‘You guys already
got the news about hurricane? India sure is catching up on
international news.’ This is a bit far-fetched. People of India
were never that ignorant. The author should have taken pains to know
the pulse of changing India.
The other instance is Vinu dialling 911
instead of 011, the telephone code of India from Canada. Is a
computer science graduate from Kochi, that ignorant? Can’t he just
simply know that 911 is an emergency number? There is another
instance where Vinu expresses wonder over the importance given to
Mahatma Gandhi in a foreign land. The author entirely forgot the fact
that even the President of the United States has a photo of Mahatma
Gandhi in his office cabin. When Barack Obama won the Nobel Peace
Prize, the whole world interpreted it as a victory of the ideals of
Gandhi.
Next
comes the language. The book lacks creative flow. Though you read
English, you will feel like you are reading Malayalam. A few examples
to show that: ‘You are on his side. Just tie him to your sari and
keep him with you forever.’; ‘Please don’t start now.’ ;
‘They will kill me then and there.’; ‘There will be fireworks
in the house now.’ (here the author is referring to the verbal duel
that is about to begin); ‘He is not a typical type....’, the list
is endless.
Some
portion of the story is like what to do to study in the USA. It seems
that the book never went to the editing table. The work of the author
could fare better if it paid attention to these details.
Interestingly,
even with these flaws, there a was moment in the book that could
bring tears in the eyes of the reader.
Even
if it’s for a second, the author could bring that emotional
element. Mistakes are of course the stepping stone to learning. A big
appreciation for the author who took the courage to put it out what
he has.
No comments:
Post a Comment
www.shaletrjimmy.blogspot.com